Most information about voluntary disclosure agreements (VDAs) tells you they are a good idea. That is true, as far as it goes. What it leaves out is the harder question every founder or CFO preparing for a sale eventually faces: is a VDA worth doing before the transaction, given this timeline, the exposure, and the states?

The answer is not always yes. Timing matters enormously. A VDA started too late in a deal process can create more uncertainty than it resolves. A VDA skipped when the exposure was material and discoverable can cost a seller far more at the closing table than the cleanup would have. And in some situations, reserving and disclosing is genuinely the right call.

This article gives you a practical framework for making that decision.

Key takeaways

  • Starting a VDA early provides more time to resolve historical liabilities before closing, but VDAs can be beneficial at almost any stage of a transaction.
  • Exposure that is material, clearly scoped, and in states with no prior contact is the strongest case for pursuing a VDA.
  • VDAs can be pursued at almost any stage of a transaction, including during due diligence. Taking proactive steps to resolve historical liabilities can demonstrate to buyers that the exposure is being addressed.
  • Unquantified exposure is more damaging in deal negotiations than disclosed, documented exposure with a plan attached.
  • The decision to pursue a VDA, reserve, or disclose depends on four variables: materiality, timeline, state contact history, and deal structure.

What a VDA Does (and Does Not Do)

A voluntary disclosure agreement is a negotiated arrangement between a business and a state taxing authority. The company comes forward before the state initiates contact, discloses its sales tax obligations, and agrees to register and pay tax going forward. In exchange, the state typically caps the look-back period (usually three or four years, regardless of how long the obligation actually existed) and reduces or eliminates penalties. As Virginia Tax’s voluntary disclosure program illustrates, the standard terms across states require the business to register, commit to future compliance, and pay tax and interest for the look-back period, in exchange for penalty waiver and the forgiveness of older periods entirely. Individual state programs vary in their specific look-back periods and penalty treatment, and terms are negotiated case by case.

Miles Consulting Group’s voluntary disclosure and liability resolution practice handles multi-state VDAs as a coordinated project, sequenced against the deal calendar rather than managed state by state in isolation. That coordination matters when exposure spans many jurisdictions and the timeline is compressed. Each state has its own application process, look-back period, and negotiating posture, and managing them in parallel rather than sequentially can shave months off the remediation timeline. One practical benefit that sellers often underestimate: for much of the process, the company can remain anonymous. In most states, a representative can approach the state on the company’s behalf, negotiate the terms, and confirm the exposure before the company’s name is ever disclosed. That means sellers can understand the full picture before committing, which matters when a transaction is on the horizon and confidentiality is a priority.

What a VDA does not do:

  • It does not erase the underlying tax obligation for the look-back period. You still owe tax on covered sales, plus interest in most states.
  • It does not resolve exposure in states where the company has already received a notice or been contacted. Those states are generally ineligible for voluntary disclosure (but sometimes still qualify at least partially).
  • It does not substitute for a nexus study or taxability analysis. A VDA resolves known exposure; it does not identify unknown exposure.

The practical value of a VDA in an M&A context is that it converts an uncertain, open-ended liability into a quantified, documented, and resolved one. That conversion is what changes how buyers treat the exposure in deal terms and what separates a clean diligence file from one that triggers escrow holdbacks or purchase price adjustments.

For B2B sellers, there is one additional tool worth knowing about before committing to the full tax amount in a VDA: an XYZ letter. This is a short request sent to customers asking them to confirm whether they self-remitted use tax on purchases from the seller. Where customers did, that portion of the exposure comes off the table. It does not change the VDA process itself, but it can meaningfully reduce the final number before the disclosure is finalized.

The Four Variables That Drive the Decision

Whether a VDA makes sense before a sale comes down to four factors. Each one can shift the answer independently, and the combination of all four is what your sales tax advisor works through before making a recommendation.

1. Materiality: is the exposure worth remediating?

Not every gap justifies a VDA. If a nexus study reveals $15,000 in exposure across two states, the cost and time of pursuing voluntary disclosure agreements likely exceeds the benefit. If the same study reveals $400,000 in exposure across eight states, the math changes entirely.

A useful rule of thumb: VDA remediation typically makes financial sense when the quantified exposure (tax plus interest) exceeds roughly $50,000, and when penalties represent a meaningful share of that number. Below that threshold, registering going forward and reserving for historical exposure is often more practical.

The more important materiality question, though, is not whether the exposure is large. It is whether a buyer will treat it as large. In middle-market tech deals, buyers and their advisors are attuned to sales tax exposure. Even modest unquantified exposure can trigger escrow requests or indemnity language that costs the seller more than the underlying tax would have.

A useful reference point: in our Miles Consulting Group case study involving a family-owned manufacturer, diligence surfaced more than $2 million in potential multi-state sales tax exposure that threatened to derail the transaction entirely. The actual liability, once properly analyzed and remediated through VDAs and penalty abatements coordinated across more than 20 states, came down by roughly $1 million. The deal closed. The headline number and the real number were very different, but only because the exposure was properly scoped and addressed before the buyer had the chance to price it on their own terms.

2. Timeline: how much runway do you have?

The earlier you identify and address sales tax exposure, the more flexibility you have. But that doesn’t mean you’ve missed the opportunity to pursue a VDA if a transaction is already underway.

VDAs can be initiated at almost any stage of the sale process, including during due diligence. Starting early gives sellers more time to identify exposure, negotiate with individual states, and complete agreements before closing. However, even when timelines are compressed, pursuing VDAs can still be a valuable step towards resolving historical liabilities.

Importantly, an ongoing VDA demonstrates that the seller has identified an issue and is actively taking steps to address it. Rather than leaving potential liabilities unresolved, the seller can provide buyers with a clear picture of the exposure, the remediation underway, and the anticipated outcome.

The key is to assess the available time, prioritize the states with the greatest exposure, and coordinate the VDA process with the transaction timetable.

3. State contact history: has the state already found you?

A VDA is only available to companies that have not yet been contacted by the state for the tax type in question. If a state has already sent a nexus questionnaire, an audit notice, or even a registration inquiry, that state is off the table for voluntary disclosure.

This matters more than sellers often realize. A company that has received notices in its three highest-exposure states may find that VDAs are only viable for lower-exposure jurisdictions, which changes the cost-benefit calculation significantly.

4. Deal structure: asset sale or stock sale?

In an asset purchase, the buyer generally does not inherit the seller’s historical tax liabilities. Successor liability rules vary by state, but asset deal structures typically give buyers more protection from pre-close exposure. In that structure, the seller’s incentive to pursue a VDA is primarily to avoid post-close indemnity claims rather than to protect the buyer directly.

In a stock sale, the buyer acquires the entity and its full liability history. That changes the buyer’s diligence focus considerably, and it raises the stakes for the seller to have clean documentation or resolved exposure before the transaction closes.

The Decision Matrix: Pursue, Reserve, or Disclose

Once you have worked through the four variables above, most situations fall into one of three paths. The table below summarizes the key conditions for each.

Scenario Recommended path
Material exposure, 18+ months to transaction, no state contact Pursue VDAs in priority states. Use the available time to resolve historical liabilities and obtain closing agreements before the transaction.
Material exposure, 6-18 months to transaction, no state contact Pursue VDAs in highest-exposure states. Accept that lower-priority states may not be resolved before close.
Material exposure, deal already in motion or LOI imminent Quantify exposure and initiate VDAs in priority states, coordinating the remediation process with the transaction timeline. Keep buyers informed of the steps being taken to resolve historical liabilities.

 

Immaterial exposure (under ~$50K), any timeline Register going forward. Consider filing historical returns to resolve past liabilities, or reserve for historical exposure. Disclose in diligence with documentation.
State contact already received in highest-exposure states VDA not available for those states. Evaluate audit defense or negotiated resolution. Pursue VDAs only in states with no prior contact.
Stock sale with significant unresolved exposure Prioritize VDAs or quantified reserves. Buyers in stock deals will price unresolved exposure aggressively.

A few important nuances:

  • Partial remediation is a legitimate strategy. Completing VDAs in your two or three highest-exposure states and reserving for the rest is a credible position. You do not need to resolve every state before a transaction.
  • Documentation matters as much as resolution. A buyer who sees a nexus study, a quantified exposure range, and a remediation plan is in a fundamentally different position than a buyer who sees a vague reference to “potential sales tax exposure.” The former is manageable. The latter becomes a negotiating tool.
  • Exemption certificate analysis can reduce the number before you remediate anything. For B2B sellers, a significant portion of historical exposure may be covered by customers’ own use tax payments or valid exemption certificates. Confirming this before pursuing VDAs can meaningfully reduce what you actually owe.

What Happens If You Skip the VDA and a Buyer Finds the Exposure

Sellers sometimes decide to skip remediation and hope diligence does not surface the issue. That is a legitimate choice in some circumstances, particularly when exposure is immaterial or when the deal timeline makes cleanup genuinely impractical. But it is worth being clear-eyed about what happens when a buyer’s advisor does find it.

Unquantified, undocumented exposure becomes a negotiating variable. Buyers who find sales tax exposure without a corresponding analysis, reserve, or remediation plan tend to do one of three things:

  • Price it aggressively. Without a seller-prepared estimate, buyers use their own assumptions, which are rarely conservative in the seller’s favor.
  • Escrow it. A common structure is to hold back 1.5x to 2x the estimated exposure in escrow, pending resolution post-close. That ties up seller proceeds for 12 to 24 months.
  • Renegotiate the purchase price. In some deals, particularly stock acquisitions, significant undisclosed exposure gives buyers leverage to reopen price discussions or restructure the deal.

The more useful framing: buyers are not trying to penalize sellers for having exposure. Most middle-market tech companies have some. The Tax Foundation’s State Tax Resource Center notes that sales tax remains the second-largest source of state tax revenue, with compliance complexity increasing as states expand their bases. What buyers are actually pricing is the uncertainty, and that is what a nexus study, a quantified reserve, or a completed VDA removes from the equation.

For a closer look at how this plays out at the closing table, see Selling Your Tech Company: How Sales Tax Exposure Could Cost You.

How to Sequence the Work Before a Transaction

A well-run pre-transaction remediation project typically follows this order:

  1. Nexus study first. Map your sales activity against each state’s economic nexus thresholds to identify where you have an obligation. This is the foundation everything else builds on. See Deal-Ready Sales Tax: A Practical Playbook for Multi-State Tech Companies for the full pre-transaction framework.
  2. Taxability analysis. Nexus tells you where you have an obligation. Taxability analysis tells you what portion of your revenue is actually taxable in each state. For SaaS and tech companies, this step often significantly reduces the exposure number, not every product or service is taxable in every state.
  3. Exemption certificate review. For B2B sellers, pull your customer list and identify which customers may have self-remitted use tax or hold valid exemption certificates. An XYZ letter to those customers can confirm this before you finalize the exposure number.
  4. VDA applications in priority states. Once the exposure is quantified and the exemption picture is clear, apply in the states where the combination of exposure size and penalty relief makes VDAs most valuable. Focus on the ones where the look-back cap and penalty waiver produce the most meaningful reduction.
  5. Reserve and document for remaining states. For states where VDAs are not viable (prior contact) or not worth the effort (immaterial exposure), prepare a documented reserve with a clear methodology. This gives buyers something concrete to evaluate rather than an open question.
  6. Assemble the diligence file. Before any buyer advisor asks for it, compile the nexus study, taxability analysis, VDA closing agreements, exemption certificate documentation, and reserve schedule into a single package. This is what turns a potential deal risk into a managed line item.

The full six-step due diligence framework is covered in Sales Tax Due Diligence in M&A: A Six-Step Framework for Finance Leaders.

Ready to assess whether a VDA makes sense before your transaction? Miles Consulting Group works with founders and CFOs preparing for a sale to scope exposure, evaluate timing, and manage multi-state remediation from nexus study through closing agreement. Learn more on our M&A Transaction Support page, or schedule a strategy call to get a clear picture before a buyer asks the same questions.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a multi-state VDA typically take?

Ideally, start as early as possible to allow time to identify exposure, negotiate agreements, and resolve historical liabilities before closing. However, VDAs can be initiated at almost any stage of a transaction, including during due diligence. Taking proactive steps to address exposure can demonstrate to buyers that historical sales tax liabilities are being managed.

Can we pursue a VDA anonymously?

Yes, for most of the process. In most states, a representative can approach the taxing authority on the company’s behalf and negotiate terms before the company’s name is ever disclosed. The company’s identity is typically only revealed when the formal agreement is executed.

What if we have already received a notice from one of the states?

A state that has already initiated contact is no longer eligible for voluntary disclosure for that tax type. For those states, the options are audit defense, a negotiated resolution, or a managed compliance agreement. Miles Consulting Group’s voluntary disclosure and liability resolution practice can advise on the right path for each state individually.

What is the look-back period for a typical VDA?

Most states cap the look-back period at three or four years under a VDA, regardless of how long the actual obligation has existed. A company that has had nexus for eight years will typically only owe tax for the most recent three or four years. The specific period varies by state and is negotiated as part of the agreement.

What does a VDA actually cost?

The cost has two components: tax and interest owed for the look-back period (penalties are typically waived), and professional fees for preparing and negotiating the agreements. The right comparison is not VDA cost versus zero. It is VDA cost versus what the same exposure would cost if a buyer’s advisor found it first.